At first he thought she might have slipped away from her hiding spot when he had been distracted by the stranger's arrival. He stood tensely, listening and after a long moment there was a rustling sound and Kaitlyn emerged just to the edge of the trees. She looked even more frightened than she had earlier, her eyes fixed on the road where the silver car had gone. The hood of her sweatshirt was pulled up over her hair and her face was pale against the dark color.
Rob followed her gaze to where the driveway met the main road and then turned back towards her, careful not to actually move towards her.
"Jess is worried sick about you. Why did you run off like that?"
"How did you do it?" Her voice was shaky but the words came out clearly.
"What?" Rob's face matched the confusion in his voice.
"How did you deny him when he asked you where I was?"
Rob paused, thinking back to the way he had felt almost compelled to turn and point out the girl's hiding place, and the tremendous effort it had taken not to. He had wanted to think that it was just a natural inclination on his part to turn towards where she had been, but as he reflected back on it, he felt a chill run down his spine at the thought of the steady, commanding eyes of the stranger, and the tone of the voice asking. Shaking his head, both to clear the chill, and to answer Kaitlyn's question he said, "I don't know."
They stood there for a moment in silence before he added, "Why don't you come back inside so we can all talk about this. I am not telling you, I'm asking you." Rob didn't know how he knew that was the right thing to say, but apparently it was because Kaitlyn crossed quickly out of the trees and back behind the barn, her eyes on the road the whole time. Rob crossed directly to the house, pausing to watch as the girl ran from behind the barn and to the back door of the house.
Jess had risen from the table and threw her arms around the girl when she entered the house. Kaitlyn flushed a little with
embarrassment, and stood stiffly, patting Jess's shoulder awkwardly. Rob couldn't help but smile at the maternal picture it brought to his mind. "Let the poor girl breathe Jess. She's not hurt."
He quickly filled her in on what had happened in the driveway, glossing over the part where he had felt compelled to answer the stranger's questions. He glanced at Kaitlyn guiltily, but she shook her head almost imperceptibly and he decided that it was best not to scare Jess any more than she already was.
When they were finished Jess looked at Kaitlyn for a long moment. "So he is...your brother?"
Kaitlyn shook her head once, but with finality.
"Who then?" Rob asked quietly.
The girl sighed, sinking into a kitchen chair as if she had no strength left in her body. Her eyes were shadowed as she pushed the hood of her sweatshirt back and stared for a long moment at the stolen loaf of bread in her other hand. She handed it back to Jess with an apology then paused again. "I don't really know how to explain it. Paul was...my friend once. Then things changed. He wanted more than what I had to give. At first he seemed to accept that I didn't feel the same about him, and we continued to be friends, but slowly, he started to somehow be a part of every aspect of my life. Other friends backed off, and it seemed like everyone else in my life was supportive of him, but not supportive of my decision to keep us just friends.
"Everywhere I turned people were gushing on about how wonderful he was, how he took such good care of me. My own parents, who hadn't even liked him at first were suddenly inviting him over to dinner all the time, and it just seemed like I couldn't get away from him."
Rob took advantage of her long pause to cut in with a question, "How long ago did all this start?"
Kaitlyn sighed again. "About three years ago. I was only seventeen, and at first I was flattered by the attention from an older guy. He didn't really start pursuing more than friendship until after I turned eighteen and graduated from high school.
"It all sounds so, innocent when I say it out loud. In some ways it even felt innocent at the time. I felt stifled, and so I took the opportunity to move away from home and go to school. I just needed to get away from my family, my friends, and especially from him. There were times that I was almost tempted to just get romantically involved with him, to get people off my back, but that never felt right to me."
Kaitlyn accepted the glass of orange juice that Jess pushed gently across the table, but she didn't drink it. It was as if once she had started her story she had to finish it.
"For six months I was doing great. I was happy. I felt free. College offered me so many opportunities to learn, and there were new friends, and boys my own age to spend time with. I didn't date anyone seriously, just went on some dates here and there. I was too busy studying to really explore a relationship at that time. There was one boy though, his name was Evan, that I spent a little more time with than anyone else. For the most part we were just friends. Neither of us were looking for anything more than that. We had some classes together and would study sometimes.
"One night we stayed up pretty late studying, talking, just enjoying each other's company. In the middle of a conversation he just leaned over and kissed me. It was a surprise to me, but I didn't mind it. It wasn't a big kiss or anything, but it changed the way things felt between us. A few minutes later Evan's car alarm went off and when he went outside to check on it someone had broken into his car. Nothing was missing but the seats had been slashed up pretty good. It kind of put a damper on the evening, so I went home.
"The next day I got a letter at my apartment. It was from Paul, and it didn't come in the mail. It was just one line. It said 'How would you feel if something happened to Evan?'
"He didn't sign it, but I knew his writing, and I knew suddenly that he was there in the town where I was living, and just as suddenly I knew that it had been him that slashed the seats of Evan's car the night before."
Kaitlyn paused, her hands shaking...